Posted by Jon Cummins on October 29, 2001 at 11:53:27:
In Reply to: Re: This is new one to me! posted by Mark Carlsen on October 29, 2001 at 10:06:57:
: : : : : : According to things I've read, Francois is sort of on the right
: : : : : : track. The carved bassbar is a throwback to the gamba family
: : : : : : of instruments. When the violin family was invented in the late
: : : : : : 1500's the carved bassbar was dispensed with and replaced with the
: : : : : : glued bassbar. The glued bass bar does a better job of supporting
: : : : : : the higher tension strings of the violin family and helps provide
: : : : : : more volume. For reasons I'm unaware of the carved bass bar (more
: : : : : : commonly called the integrated bass bar) was still used by some
: : : : : : makers for awhile though it's inferiority was known. I believe I read
: : : : : : an article in Bass World by Barrie Kolstein, and I also think _A New
: : : : : : History of the Doublebass_ by Paul Brun touches on the subject.
: : : : : : Judging by the description of the bass (wooden pegs, integrated bass bar),
: : : : : : I'd guess it's probably older than 60 years.
: : : : : I would have to agree with you for the most part.Why do most basses have glued Bass bars today?My whole point with Francois's statement is that you can have a carved bass bar and the instrument is not useless.Has Francois acually played a bass with an integrated Bass bar?And his point that it must be glued I felt was not 100% correct.Thats all I'm saying, My 2 cents worth.
: : : : Mark:
: : : : I said that a carved bassbar was useless, not the instument.
: : : : It seems we agree that these integrated bass bars are found on cheaper instruments. And that nowadays, all good instruments use a glued carved bassbar.
: : : : "Obviously someone with very little knowledge on the subject." is what you told me.
: : : : This is not true and was't very inspiring to get a positive idea exchange.
: : : Francois:Well I guess my Cheap insrument sounds alot better than than most expensive glued types.Again do you have experience w. a cheap integrated model? Are you a Luthier? Are you inspired to answer the Questions?
: : Mark:
: : 1-Yes
: : 2-Not exactly. I've studied luthery for one year and built a tenor violin (the size of a 3/4 cello)
: : 3-Not yours
: : End of thread as far as I'm concerned.
: "The Great Oz has Spoken"
: Now boy's be kind! I thank everyone their for opinions, and now my knowledge is greater on this subject.
Post a Followup